*dzoink*

marco:

Here’s where this insulting, degrading video to real geeks went wrong.

While some people in it are really geeks, most aren’t, and the inclusion of some is baffling. Being a popular user of a “new media” site, or being a “new media” celebrity, doesn’t make you a geek. There’s absolutely no connection whatsoever. This video tarnishes true geek culture with new-media celebrities because — surprise — it was made by new-media people, many of whom try to be cool by saying that they’re geeks (which, in addition to being far from the truth, is guaranteed to insult and frustrate actual geeks).

Being a good user of computers and internet-based services stopped being a geek-exclusive behavior a very long time ago. Geek culture isn’t something that a Twitter celebrity suddenly enters because Twitter was written by programmers and runs on servers.

I could rant about this for much longer, but anyone who can tolerate my tumblelog for more than a few sentences is much more likely to be a geek than half of the people in this video, so I’m preaching to the choir.

*standing ovation*

marco:

Here’s where this insulting, degrading video to real geeks went wrong.

While some people in it are really geeks, most aren’t, and the inclusion of some is baffling. Being a popular user of a “new media” site, or being a “new media” celebrity, doesn’t make you a geek. There’s absolutely no connection whatsoever. This video tarnishes true geek culture with new-media celebrities because — surprise — it was made by new-media people, many of whom try to be cool by saying that they’re geeks (which, in addition to being far from the truth, is guaranteed to insult and frustrate actual geeks).

Being a good user of computers and internet-based services stopped being a geek-exclusive behavior a very long time ago. Geek culture isn’t something that a Twitter celebrity suddenly enters because Twitter was written by programmers and runs on servers.

I could rant about this for much longer, but anyone who can tolerate my tumblelog for more than a few sentences is much more likely to be a geek than half of the people in this video, so I’m preaching to the choir.

*standing ovation*

  1. jacque reblogged this from marco and added:
    I cannot even begin...put my frustration into words at this whole #iamageek business. Most...
  2. scrufus reblogged this from marco
  3. ak7 reblogged this from marco
  4. gurupanguji reblogged this from marco
  5. jensenrf reblogged this from marco
  6. naluna reblogged this from kappachan
  7. jostle reblogged this from marco
  8. lauraglu reblogged this from timoni and added:
    I think that by *doing it for charity* these kids were hoping to avoid backlash. meh FWIW I am not really a tech geek....
  9. ajamison reblogged this from marco
  10. doubletheecho reblogged this from g-funk
  11. timoni reblogged this from marco and added:
    write something longer about...intro video to geekadvancement.com, but Marco’s already...
  12. nicolelee reblogged this from emptyage and added:
    See, this is why I prefer to be a nerd. I can wallow in my own shallow mudpool of isolation and unhipness as I push up...
  13. kappachan reblogged this from marco and added:
    *standing ovation*